My suggestion is for a new feature:
The winners in arena tournaments top 3 that normally gets automatic a trophy should have the option to accept the trophy or not.
If they don't accept the trophy it goes to the next person in line.
Example the person winning the gold trophy for some reason feel he should not have won, maybe his opponent got disconnected in critical game can then just decline the trophy.
The player second will then get the gold, the player third will get the silver and the player 4th will now also get a trophy..
My suggestion is for a new feature:
The winners in arena tournaments top 3 that normally gets automatic a trophy should have the option to accept the trophy or not.
If they don't accept the trophy it goes to the next person in line.
Example the person winning the gold trophy for some reason feel he should not have won, maybe his opponent got disconnected in critical game can then just decline the trophy.
The player second will then get the gold, the player third will get the silver and the player 4th will now also get a trophy..
so in theory, the person in third last, second last, and last place could get a trophy if everyone above them had declined for whatever reason
would you see any issue with that
so in theory, the person in third last, second last, and last place could get a trophy if everyone above them had declined for whatever reason
would you see any issue with that
Those trophies don't show up anywhere after the tournament ended anyway...
But if you won, you won. I don't see any reason to change that. My guess is nobody would ever use this. Seems like a bad idea to complicate things without any benefit at all.
Those trophies don't show up anywhere after the tournament ended anyway...
But if you won, you won. I don't see any reason to change that. My guess is nobody would ever use this. Seems like a bad idea to complicate things without any benefit at all.
So, in theory, you want people to give up the prized possession that they earned through hard work and just give it to someone who didn't even get top 3?
So, in theory, you want people to give up the *prized possession that they earned through hard work* and just give it to someone who didn't even get top 3?
Strange the people that reply never won trophies but they got some comments to share. Please reply to post if you win at least a trophy every week in an arean event. Else keep your opinion to yourself.
Strange the people that reply never won trophies but they got some comments to share. Please reply to post if you win at least a trophy every week in an arean event. Else keep your opinion to yourself.
@g6firste6second said in #2:
so in theory, the person in third last, second last, and last place could get a trophy if everyone above them had declined for whatever reason
would you see any issue with that
no i won't see an issue with that if that was the choice of the players above them..
@g6firste6second said in #2:
> so in theory, the person in third last, second last, and last place could get a trophy if everyone above them had declined for whatever reason
>
> would you see any issue with that
no i won't see an issue with that if that was the choice of the players above them..
@Xyqon said in #6:
so in theory, the person in third last, second last, and last place could get a trophy if everyone above them had declined for whatever reason
would you see any issue with that
no i won't see an issue with that if that was the choice of the players above them..
There's a real problem here related to trophy transfer. When someone gets banned in a marathon, the players move up a position. Someone who was 501st now ranks 500th, but they don't get a globe in their profile. And you're talking about a much more complex system: the winner stays first, but gives up the trophy. Frankly, this is just plain stupid.
@Xyqon said in #6:
> so in theory, the person in third last, second last, and last place could get a trophy if everyone above them had declined for whatever reason
>
> would you see any issue with that
>
> no i won't see an issue with that if that was the choice of the players above them..
There's a real problem here related to trophy transfer. When someone gets banned in a marathon, the players move up a position. Someone who was 501st now ranks 500th, but they don't get a globe in their profile. And you're talking about a much more complex system: the winner stays first, but gives up the trophy. Frankly, this is just plain stupid.
I propose to expand this idea:
Let users above to take back trophy at any time. For example when trophy will reach last place first place could take back trophy and repeat the cycle. So we can play hot potato with trophy!
I propose to expand this idea:
Let users above to take back trophy at any time. For example when trophy will reach last place first place could take back trophy and repeat the cycle. So we can play hot potato with trophy!
@Xyqon said in #5:
Strange the people that reply never won trophies but they got some comments to share. Please reply to post if you win at least a trophy every week in an arean event. Else keep your opinion to yourself.
You propose an idea that could lead to result where anyone here could get a trophy if players above them in the tournament table will reject trophy. So it is completely normal that any user can say their opinion about this topic. Also there are no restrictions about who can can reply in this section of the forum. No to mention that if someone here didn't get the a trophy yet it doesn't mean that he will no be able to do it in the future.
@Xyqon said in #5:
> Strange the people that reply never won trophies but they got some comments to share. Please reply to post if you win at least a trophy every week in an arean event. Else keep your opinion to yourself.
You propose an idea that could lead to result where anyone here could get a trophy if players above them in the tournament table will reject trophy. So it is completely normal that any user can say their opinion about this topic. Also there are no restrictions about who can can reply in this section of the forum. No to mention that if someone here didn't get the a trophy yet it doesn't mean that he will no be able to do it in the future.
If you score more points than the 2nd place finisher then you deserved to win
If you score more points than the 2nd place finisher then you deserved to win