lichess.org
Donate

NEW Feature request: Let winners in arenas top3 be able to accept trophy or not

@Xyqon said in #6:

so in theory, the person in third last, second last, and last place could get a trophy if everyone above them had declined for whatever reason

would you see any issue with that

no i won't see an issue with that if that was the choice of the players above them..

the issue is the third last person could receive 1st trophy, second last 2nd trophy, last place 3rd trophy, while potentially losing all their games, so why bother with trophies since anyone could get one?

@Xyqon said in #6: > so in theory, the person in third last, second last, and last place could get a trophy if everyone above them had declined for whatever reason > > would you see any issue with that > > no i won't see an issue with that if that was the choice of the players above them.. the issue is the third last person could receive 1st trophy, second last 2nd trophy, last place 3rd trophy, while potentially losing all their games, so why bother with trophies since anyone could get one?

@Italiya said in #7:

so in theory, the person in third last, second last, and last place could get a trophy if everyone above them had declined for whatever reason

would you see any issue with that

no i won't see an issue with that if that was the choice of the players above them..

There's a real problem here related to trophy transfer. When someone gets banned in a marathon, the players move up a position. Someone who was 501st now ranks 500th, but they don't get a globe in their profile. And you're talking about a much more complex system: the winner stays first, but gives up the trophy. Frankly, this is just plain stupid.

trust the above comment make sense now imagine what if u can see the future you will think great feature!

@Italiya said in #7: > so in theory, the person in third last, second last, and last place could get a trophy if everyone above them had declined for whatever reason > > would you see any issue with that > > no i won't see an issue with that if that was the choice of the players above them.. > > There's a real problem here related to trophy transfer. When someone gets banned in a marathon, the players move up a position. Someone who was 501st now ranks 500th, but they don't get a globe in their profile. And you're talking about a much more complex system: the winner stays first, but gives up the trophy. Frankly, this is just plain stupid. trust the above comment make sense now imagine what if u can see the future you will think great feature!

you got thumbs down from thibault - great achievement. Also deserved for the rude and pretentious attitude in #5.

you got thumbs down from thibault - great achievement. Also deserved for the rude and pretentious attitude in #5.

This topic has been archived and can no longer be replied to.