lichess.org
Donate

Game from a tournament with Magnus

Hello dear community,
this is my first post in this part of the forum, the section about chess analysis. I’ve inserted an image here from a blog on Lichess. I hope that’s allowed. If there are any copyright issues, I’ll delete this post again.

My question now would be: is this position actually necessarily lost for Magnus Carlsen? I know that king and rook versus king is a clear win, but the moment the weaker side still has a knight, the win can no longer be forced — or at least that has always been my understanding. In that case, shouldn’t the game actually be a draw, or am I seeing this wrong?
SmartSelect_20260510_081341_Samsung Internet.jpg

Hello dear community, this is my first post in this part of the forum, the section about chess analysis. I’ve inserted an image here from a blog on Lichess. I hope that’s allowed. If there are any copyright issues, I’ll delete this post again. My question now would be: is this position actually necessarily lost for Magnus Carlsen? I know that king and rook versus king is a clear win, but the moment the weaker side still has a knight, the win can no longer be forced — or at least that has always been my understanding. In that case, shouldn’t the game actually be a draw, or am I seeing this wrong? ![SmartSelect_20260510_081341_Samsung Internet.jpg](https://image.lichess1.org/display?fmt=webp&h=0&op=resize&path=LVKoJCIwM8uc.jpg&w=864&sig=225e5c98c6a509fe9a67d91213b5ea25a0a53120)

"is this position actually necessarily lost for Magnus Carlsen?"

  • Yes. It is a table base win for white.

"the moment the weaker side still has a knight, the win can no longer be forced"

  • That is not true: there are positions where K+R force a win against K+N by trapping the knight.
"is this position actually necessarily lost for Magnus Carlsen?" * Yes. It is a table base win for white. "the moment the weaker side still has a knight, the win can no longer be forced" * That is not true: there are positions where K+R force a win against K+N by trapping the knight.

Okay, thank you, @tpr.

Learned something new again...

I actually had to look up “tablebase” first.

Thx

Okay, thank you, @tpr. Learned something new again... I actually had to look up “tablebase” first. Thx

Let’s see, I’ll give Stockfish 12 a little chance...

Screenshot_20260510_110307.jpg

Let’s see, I’ll give Stockfish 12 a little chance... ![Screenshot_20260510_110307.jpg](https://image.lichess1.org/display?fmt=webp&h=0&op=resize&path=1RoqrInGVSct.jpg&w=864&sig=66b997942f4ce6b43badb4e911d6403df5af1ae3)

This topic has been archived and can no longer be replied to.