lichess.org
Donate

Back to Middle Ages

On one hand: I think execution can be justified in this case. Whenever you get treason, terrorism, and mass murder all rolled into a single instance, that’s pretty much the ideal circumstances for an execution. I get why there is moral opposition to the concept of execution, but I can’t see any reason why, supposing a system that incorporates capital punishment into its justice system, this would be an inappropriate time to use it.

On the flip side: live-streamed execution? Messed up.
If you’ve ever seen death, you know it’s not something that should be marketed as a general spectacle. Live-streaming doesn’t add any additional complications for would be killers, so it’s not an effective deterrent. It’s merely a way to satisfy blood-lust.

On one hand: I think execution can be justified in this case. Whenever you get treason, terrorism, and mass murder all rolled into a single instance, that’s pretty much the ideal circumstances for an execution. I get why there is moral opposition to the concept of execution, but I can’t see any reason why, supposing a system that incorporates capital punishment into its justice system, this would be an inappropriate time to use it. On the flip side: *live-streamed* execution? Messed up. If you’ve ever seen death, you know it’s not something that should be marketed as a general spectacle. Live-streaming doesn’t add any additional complications for would be killers, so it’s not an effective deterrent. It’s merely a way to satisfy blood-lust.

@clousems said ^

On one hand: I think execution can be justified in this case. Whenever you get treason, terrorism, and mass murder all rolled into a single instance, that’s pretty much the ideal circumstances for an execution. I get why there is moral opposition to the concept of execution, but I can’t see any reason why, supposing a system that incorporates capital punishment into its justice system, this would be an inappropriate time to use it.

Even if I strongly believe monsters like him ( I won't write his name here ) are fearing rotting anonymously in jail more than execution . My point was not against the execution . What is wrong is making it a public show .

@clousems said [^](/forum/redirect/post/1ikSPvSy) >On one hand: I think execution can be justified in this case. Whenever you get treason, terrorism, and mass murder all rolled into a single instance, that’s pretty much the ideal circumstances for an execution. I get why there is moral opposition to the concept of execution, but I can’t see any reason why, supposing a system that incorporates capital punishment into its justice system, this would be an inappropriate time to use it. Even if I strongly believe monsters like him ( I won't write his name here ) are fearing rotting anonymously in jail more than execution . My point was not against the execution . **What is wrong is making it a public show** .

"it’s not an effective deterrent"

  • On the contrary, it may create a martyr and attract followers.
"it’s not an effective deterrent" * On the contrary, it may create a martyr and attract followers.