lichess.org
Donate

Why did Humpy Koneru withdraw?

The primary "problem" surrounding the FIDE Candidates Tournament 2026 in Cyprus is a combination of security concerns and infrastructure issues, which have led to a high-profile player withdrawal and public criticism from top contenders.

  1. Security Concerns & Player Withdrawal
    The most significant issue is the perceived safety risk due to the ongoing conflict in West Asia (Middle East) involving the US, Israel, and Iran.

Koneru Humpy’s Withdrawal: India’s top female player, GM Koneru Humpy, officially withdrew from the Women's Candidates on March 22, 2026. She stated that "no event... can come before personal safety and well-being".

Regional Tensions: Players and fans have expressed unease after a drone strike reportedly hit a British air base on the island (RAF Akrotiri) on March 1, 2026.

Replacement: Ukraine's Anna Muzychuk has been named as Humpy's replacement for the tournament.

  1. Infrastructure & Playing Conditions
    Top-seeded American GM Hikaru Nakamura has publicly flagged concerns regarding the island's stability.

Power Outages: Nakamura reported frequent and total power cuts in parts of Cyprus that lasted for extended periods, calling it "not a good sign" for a world-class elite tournament.

Impact on Prep: Since many players, including Nakamura, set up training camps in Cyprus weeks in advance, these outages have directly disrupted their final preparations.

  1. FIDE’s Response & Controversy
    Despite these issues, FIDE has maintained that the tournament will proceed as scheduled in Paphos.

Official Stance: FIDE CEO Emil Sutovsky stated that Cyprus is not in a state of war or emergency and that the situation is being "constantly monitored" in coordination with state authorities.

Venue Relocation Offer: Reports indicate that German billionaire Wadim Rosenstein offered to move the entire tournament to Germany and cover all logistical costs to ensure safety, but FIDE declined the offer.

Potential Fines: Regulations for the tournament include a potential fine of up to €10,000 for players who withdraw without a "satisfactory reason" after signing their contracts, adding a layer of financial pressure to the safety concerns.

The primary "problem" surrounding the FIDE Candidates Tournament 2026 in Cyprus is a combination of security concerns and infrastructure issues, which have led to a high-profile player withdrawal and public criticism from top contenders. 1. Security Concerns & Player Withdrawal The most significant issue is the perceived safety risk due to the ongoing conflict in West Asia (Middle East) involving the US, Israel, and Iran. Koneru Humpy’s Withdrawal: India’s top female player, GM Koneru Humpy, officially withdrew from the Women's Candidates on March 22, 2026. She stated that "no event... can come before personal safety and well-being". Regional Tensions: Players and fans have expressed unease after a drone strike reportedly hit a British air base on the island (RAF Akrotiri) on March 1, 2026. Replacement: Ukraine's Anna Muzychuk has been named as Humpy's replacement for the tournament. 2. Infrastructure & Playing Conditions Top-seeded American GM Hikaru Nakamura has publicly flagged concerns regarding the island's stability. Power Outages: Nakamura reported frequent and total power cuts in parts of Cyprus that lasted for extended periods, calling it "not a good sign" for a world-class elite tournament. Impact on Prep: Since many players, including Nakamura, set up training camps in Cyprus weeks in advance, these outages have directly disrupted their final preparations. 3. FIDE’s Response & Controversy Despite these issues, FIDE has maintained that the tournament will proceed as scheduled in Paphos. Official Stance: FIDE CEO Emil Sutovsky stated that Cyprus is not in a state of war or emergency and that the situation is being "constantly monitored" in coordination with state authorities. Venue Relocation Offer: Reports indicate that German billionaire Wadim Rosenstein offered to move the entire tournament to Germany and cover all logistical costs to ensure safety, but FIDE declined the offer. Potential Fines: Regulations for the tournament include a potential fine of up to €10,000 for players who withdraw without a "satisfactory reason" after signing their contracts, adding a layer of financial pressure to the safety concerns.

The risk is always non-zero.

For example you could get out of bed, trip, land in the wrong way and hit your head and die. The risk of it happening is extremely low but not zero. Around 450 people die per year getting out of bed while shark attacks result in around 70 deaths per year yet many people fear sharks more than their bed...

Being realistic I consider the risk to participants to be very low. Since the Iran war has started there have been literally zero casualties yet alone fatalities in Cyprus due to the conflict. It's probably on the same level as not wanting to compete in USA cause there are lots of guns and there could be a mass shooting event at the competition. It's possible but not very likely.

Having said that if Humpy Koneru is worried about that and would be anxious or having panic attacks while unable to focus on her chess during the event then it's sensible not taking part. At the end of the day while I don't agree with her reasoning she has to do what is right for her physical and emotional wellbeing so I respect her decision.

The risk is always non-zero. For example you could get out of bed, trip, land in the wrong way and hit your head and die. The risk of it happening is extremely low but not zero. Around 450 people die per year getting out of bed while shark attacks result in around 70 deaths per year yet many people fear sharks more than their bed... Being realistic I consider the risk to participants to be very low. Since the Iran war has started there have been literally zero casualties yet alone fatalities in Cyprus due to the conflict. It's probably on the same level as not wanting to compete in USA cause there are lots of guns and there could be a mass shooting event at the competition. It's possible but not very likely. Having said that if Humpy Koneru is worried about that and would be anxious or having panic attacks while unable to focus on her chess during the event then it's sensible not taking part. At the end of the day while I don't agree with her reasoning she has to do what is right for her physical and emotional wellbeing so I respect her decision.

"The risk is always non-zero."

  • But in Cyprus it may be higher than in Germany.
    Anyway, if Humpy Koneru perceives the risk as too high, then she is right to withdraw.
    Likewise Radjabov in 2020 perceived the risk of COVID too high and he withdrew from Candidates'.
"The risk is always non-zero." * But in Cyprus it may be higher than in Germany. Anyway, if Humpy Koneru perceives the risk as too high, then she is right to withdraw. Likewise Radjabov in 2020 perceived the risk of COVID too high and he withdrew from Candidates'.

Indian chess player Koneru has withdrawn from the Women's Candidates Tournament due to concerns for her safety.

Indian chess player Koneru has withdrawn from the Women's Candidates Tournament due to concerns for her safety.

A brief history lesson- candidates having issues with the location is nothing new and goes back to the very first tournament in 1950.
This was intended to be the top 9 players selected from the Interzonal tournament, plus the 4 participants in the previous world championship (Reshevsky, Euwe, Keres, Smyslov) plus Fine who was invited for the world championship but declined to play.
There were two bids to organise the tournament from Argentina and Hungary. Argentina was the popular choice but the USSR who dominated FIDE demanded Hungary. Visa problems meant that Reshevsky and Fine from the US could no longer play while Euwe was not available. No doubt the Soviets were very happy with the three main Western rivals knocked out. Bondarevsky, one of the Soviet qualifiers from the Interzonal, declined his spot and that's how the candidates were reduced from 14 to 10.
By the way, the tournament ended in a tie between Bronstein and Boleslavsky. Bronstein won the playoff match but many years later said the result was fixed.

A brief history lesson- candidates having issues with the location is nothing new and goes back to the very first tournament in 1950. This was intended to be the top 9 players selected from the Interzonal tournament, plus the 4 participants in the previous world championship (Reshevsky, Euwe, Keres, Smyslov) plus Fine who was invited for the world championship but declined to play. There were two bids to organise the tournament from Argentina and Hungary. Argentina was the popular choice but the USSR who dominated FIDE demanded Hungary. Visa problems meant that Reshevsky and Fine from the US could no longer play while Euwe was not available. No doubt the Soviets were very happy with the three main Western rivals knocked out. Bondarevsky, one of the Soviet qualifiers from the Interzonal, declined his spot and that's how the candidates were reduced from 14 to 10. By the way, the tournament ended in a tie between Bronstein and Boleslavsky. Bronstein won the playoff match but many years later said the result was fixed.