@EmaciatedSpaniard said in #19:
Thanks for the feedback on my study! I think I wrote most of those things. There is indeed the trick that black can double attack pawn and knight with the queen to win the e-pawn. Later when white's e-pawn is defended, black plays b5 to remove the threat of knight-capture and drive back the bishop. But I didn't want to overload this beginner study. Do you think i should add all that?
I, personally, think you should add that information because that is the main reason white & black are doing those moves.
I am at work so I can’t write a lot at the moment.
However, I wanted to tell you about a few other things.
After black plays 4...Nf6, White main line move isn’t defending the e4 pawn.
The main line move is for white to castle 5. O-O.
At this point, Black has a few moves they can play.
Black could take the pawn on e4 with their knight, BUT they can’t keep it!
If Black tries to stay 1 pawn up, they will often end up checkmated with their king stuck in the center of the board.
Usually, Black takes the pawn.
Than they let white gain back a pawn so the position is equal in material.
While white spends time retaking the pawn, Black gets castles so their King is safe.
Remember, this opening is a battle of ideas!
White wants to win black e5 pawn, but can’t right away due to tactical reasons.
Black wants to win white e4 pawn, but can’t right away due to tactical reasons.
Don’t get me wrong the Open: Ruy Lopez is 100% playable.
The issue is Black can’t be greedy when they play it.
For the above reasons, The Open: Ruy Lopez doesn’t get played a lot! Lol
Chess Players want to be greedy!
The main line move for Black on move 5 isn’t a Knight move.
It is 5...Be7.
The move Bishop to e7 carries a deadly threat.
The threat is for Black to take e4 pawn with Knight on move 6!
Previous, it takes black 2 moves to castle.
They have to move bishop + castle.
In this position, the bishop has already moved.
This means black only needs 1 move to castle.
That 1 move difference makes a huge difference because now Black idea is to take e4 pawn and hold on to it forever! An they don’t have to worry about there King safety due to being only 1 move away.
Lucky for white! They have star move at move 6 which saves their bacon!
The star move is 6. Re1.
The rook move does 2 difference things simultaneously!
The first thing it does is defend the E4 pawn which eliminates black ideas of taking it.
The second thing it does is set up whites “later” threat.
White also had an idea to take knight on c6 with bishop.
Than take the e5 pawn with his knight.
White couldn’t do the threat because black had a tactic which double attacked the undefended e4 pawn + white knight.
The issue is the rook move defends the e4 pawn so now black tactic is no longer working.
On the next move if black does stupid move white is going for it!
At this moment, Black “later” defense kicks in!.
The a6 pawn move on move 3 is helping black defend!
The a6 pawn supports blacks B pawn!
The a6 moves allows black to play 6...b5 breaking the pin on the Knight
This eliminates whites threat of chopping the knight.
@EmaciatedSpaniard said in #19:
> Thanks for the feedback on my study! I think I wrote most of those things. There is indeed the trick that black can double attack pawn and knight with the queen to win the e-pawn. Later when white's e-pawn is defended, black plays b5 to remove the threat of knight-capture and drive back the bishop. But I didn't want to overload this beginner study. Do you think i should add all that?
I, personally, think you should add that information because that is the main reason white & black are doing those moves.
I am at work so I can’t write a lot at the moment.
However, I wanted to tell you about a few other things.
After black plays 4...Nf6, White main line move isn’t defending the e4 pawn.
The main line move is for white to castle 5. O-O.
At this point, Black has a few moves they can play.
Black could take the pawn on e4 with their knight, BUT they can’t keep it!
If Black tries to stay 1 pawn up, they will often end up checkmated with their king stuck in the center of the board.
Usually, Black takes the pawn.
Than they let white gain back a pawn so the position is equal in material.
While white spends time retaking the pawn, Black gets castles so their King is safe.
Remember, this opening is a battle of ideas!
White wants to win black e5 pawn, but can’t right away due to tactical reasons.
Black wants to win white e4 pawn, but can’t right away due to tactical reasons.
Don’t get me wrong the Open: Ruy Lopez is 100% playable.
The issue is Black can’t be greedy when they play it.
For the above reasons, The Open: Ruy Lopez doesn’t get played a lot! Lol
Chess Players want to be greedy!
The main line move for Black on move 5 isn’t a Knight move.
It is 5...Be7.
The move Bishop to e7 carries a deadly threat.
The threat is for Black to take e4 pawn with Knight on move 6!
Previous, it takes black 2 moves to castle.
They have to move bishop + castle.
In this position, the bishop has already moved.
This means black only needs 1 move to castle.
That 1 move difference makes a huge difference because now Black idea is to take e4 pawn and hold on to it forever! An they don’t have to worry about there King safety due to being only 1 move away.
Lucky for white! They have star move at move 6 which saves their bacon!
The star move is 6. Re1.
The rook move does 2 difference things simultaneously!
The first thing it does is defend the E4 pawn which eliminates black ideas of taking it.
The second thing it does is set up whites “later” threat.
White also had an idea to take knight on c6 with bishop.
Than take the e5 pawn with his knight.
White couldn’t do the threat because black had a tactic which double attacked the undefended e4 pawn + white knight.
The issue is the rook move defends the e4 pawn so now black tactic is no longer working.
On the next move if black does stupid move white is going for it!
At this moment, Black “later” defense kicks in!.
The a6 pawn move on move 3 is helping black defend!
The a6 pawn supports blacks B pawn!
The a6 moves allows black to play 6...b5 breaking the pin on the Knight
This eliminates whites threat of chopping the knight.